The Social Security Scam That Costs Seniors Billions – And How an Estate Plan Helps Stop It

Someone calls your parent and says their Social Security number has been suspended due to suspicious activity. To protect their benefits, they need to verify their identity immediately. Or pay a fine. Or move their savings to a “secure” account. The caller sounds official, urgent, and convincing, and federal officials estimate that government-impersonation schemes like this one cost older Americans billions of dollars every year. These are not isolated incidents. They are the most commonly reported type of elder fraud in the United States, and they work because they are designed to.

Awareness helps. But the most durable protection for an aging parent is not a list of red flags. It is a legal and financial structure that limits what a scammer can reach in the first place.

FREE WEBINAR

5 Things to Know About

Estate Planning

When You Turn Sixty-Five

Save the Date

Friday, Sep 18^th at 2:30pm

Why Scammers Target Older Adults

Scammers do not target older adults because they are less capable. They target this population because they may have accumulated savings, established credit, and less familiarity with newer digital tactics. They also tend to answer the phone, which puts them in direct contact with fraudsters in a way that younger adults who screen calls more aggressively are not.

Government-impersonation scams are among the most reported types of elder fraud precisely because they exploit trust in institutions. A caller claiming to represent the Social Security Administration, the Department of Health and Human Services, or Medicare carries an assumed legitimacy that a random stranger does not. When that caller already has some personal information, a name, a partial account number, a benefit amount, the approach can feel credible enough to prompt action before skepticism sets in.

How These Scams Work: The Four-Stage Pattern

Regardless of the specific story a scammer uses, government-impersonation schemes follow a remarkably consistent pattern. Recognizing the pattern is more useful than trying to memorize every variation, because the variations change constantly while the structure does not.

Pretend. The scammer claims to represent a trusted source, such as the Social Security Administration, the HHS Office of the Inspector General, a bank, or a well-known company. They may already have some of the target’s personal information, which makes the approach feel legitimate.

Prize or problem. The scammer either offers something appealing, such as a benefit increase or a prize, or creates fear by claiming there is a serious problem, such as a suspended Social Security number or a fraud alert on an account.

Pressure. They tell the person to act immediately, often to avoid arrest or to protect benefits or accounts, leaving little time to verify the claim or speak with a family member.

Payment. The scammer requests payment or personal data through unusual channels, such as gift cards, wire transfers, cryptocurrency, cash delivered in person, or a Social Security or Medicare number provided to confirm eligibility.

The single rule that can prevent most of these encounters: no legitimate government agency will ever ask someone to move money to protect it, demand payment by gift card or cryptocurrency, or ask for a Social Security number to determine benefit eligibility. That rule alone, known and applied consistently, stops most impersonation scams before they go anywhere.

Practical Steps Families Can Take Now

Protect personal information at the source. A scammer’s ability to seem credible depends on how much they already know. Sensitive information, including Social Security numbers, Medicare numbers, bank account details, and online passwords, should never be shared with unsolicited callers, regardless of who they claim to be. Caller ID can be spoofed. A government agency’s name appearing on a screen does not prove the call is legitimate.

Verify through independent channels. Any unexpected contact claiming to be from a government agency should be treated with skepticism until verified. The right response is to hang up and call the agency back using a number found independently on the agency’s official website, not a number provided by the person who called. The same applies to links in emails and text messages.

Treat urgency and secrecy as warning signs. Legitimate government agencies do not demand immediate action or ask a beneficiary to keep a conversation confidential from family members. Pressure to act immediately and instructions not to tell anyone are signatures of a scam, not a government procedure.

Create a family plan in advance. Families can significantly reduce fraud risk by agreeing ahead of time on how to handle unexpected calls or requests involving benefits or personal information. Designating a trusted contact, establishing a family code word to verify genuine emergencies, and setting up account alerts with the older adult’s permission are all practical steps that cost nothing and can prevent a great deal of harm.

Monitor accounts and official records. Creating a my Social Security account at ssa.gov allows a beneficiary or a trusted family member to track benefit statements and catch unauthorized changes. With permission, family members can also set up alerts on bank and investment accounts for large withdrawals, unusual purchases, or transfers to new recipients.

What to Do If a Scam Has Already Occurred

If an older adult has shared sensitive information or sent money to a scammer, the response matters and speed matters more than most people realize. Contact the relevant bank or credit card company immediately to limit further loss. Consider placing a fraud alert or credit freeze with the major credit bureaus. Report Social Security-related scams to the SSA Office of Inspector General fraud hotline. Report Medicare and HHS program fraud through the HHS-OIG hotline. File a general fraud report with the Federal Trade Commission.

Report suspected scams even if no money changed hands. Reports help investigators identify patterns, warn the public, and shut down schemes that may be targeting others in the same community.

Where Estate Planning Fits In

Awareness and family communication reduce fraud risk. Legal structure reduces it further, and in ways that awareness alone cannot.

A durable power of attorney names a trusted person to manage an older adult’s financial affairs if they become unable to do so themselves. This document does not prevent a parent from managing their own money while they are capable. It helps ensure that someone the individual has chosen is legally authorized to assist when appropriate, if the document has been properly prepared and becomes effective under its terms. A family member with existing legal authority may be able to work more quickly with financial institutions, investigate suspicious transactions, help protect remaining assets, and take appropriate legal or financial steps depending on the circumstances.

A healthcare proxy provides a parallel protection for medical decisions, which matters in situations where cognitive decline, medication, or illness reduces a parent’s ability to evaluate information accurately.

A trust can provide an additional structural layer. Assets held in a properly structured trust are managed by a trustee according to the trust’s terms. Depending on the trust structure and how it is drafted, this can limit the ability of a scammer or an exploitative individual to convince a vulnerable person to transfer assets in ways that are difficult to reverse. It can also ensure that a co-trustee or successor trustee has visibility into account activity.

Trusted contact designations on financial accounts are a newer and underused tool. Many banks and investment firms now allow account holders to designate a trusted contact, a person the institution can reach out to if they observe unusual activity or have concerns about potential exploitation. The trusted contact does not have authority over the account. They simply give the financial institution someone to call if something looks wrong. Adding a trusted contact is a simple step that can create an important early warning system.

None of these tools guarantee that a parent will never be targeted by a scammer. Scammers are persistent and adaptable. What these tools do is reduce the window of opportunity, create checkpoints, and give families legal authority to respond quickly when something goes wrong.

Plan Well. Live Better.

Protecting an aging parent from financial exploitation is partly a matter of education and partly a matter of structure. At Milvidskiy Law Group, we help New Jersey families put the legal tools in place that limit what a scammer can reach, give trusted family members the authority they need to act, and build estate plans that account for the realities of aging, including the ones no one wants to think about until they have to. Learn more about our estate planning services.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Estate planning and elder law are highly individual. What is right for one family may not be right for another. We encourage you to speak with a qualified attorney to discuss your specific situation.